HEIC vs JPG: what you lose and gain by converting
HEIC is the more efficient format and JPG the more compatible one. Keep the HEIC as your master copy and make a JPG only for the places that refuse HEIC, because the conversion drops depth, HDR and Live Photo data and cannot be undone.
ConvertBoxPublished
What a HEIC file actually is
HEIF, the High Efficiency Image File Format, is a container standardised by MPEG. HEIC is the name used for a HEIF file whose picture is compressed with HEVC, also known as H.265, the codec used for 4K video. iPhones have saved photos this way by default since iOS 11, under a camera setting called High Efficiency.
The saving comes from how the codec works. JPEG, which dates from 1992, cuts the picture into fixed 8 x 8 pixel blocks and compresses each one on its own. HEVC predicts every block from neighbours it has already encoded and stores only the difference, and it varies the block size from 4 x 4 up to 64 x 64, so a flat sky costs very few bits and the detail gets the rest. The result is often about half the size of a JPEG of similar visual quality. A 12-megapixel photo that takes roughly 2 MB as HEIC typically takes 3 to 4 MB as JPEG, so a library of 1,000 photos is about 2 GB instead of 3 to 4 GB.
HEIC and JPG side by side
Neither format is lossless in normal camera use: both discard detail the eye is unlikely to miss. HEIC spends fewer bits to reach the same look, and JPG is understood by practically every device and program made in the last thirty years.
| HEIC | JPG | |
|---|---|---|
| Compression | HEVC: prediction between blocks, variable block sizes | DCT on fixed 8 x 8 blocks |
| Size at similar quality | Often about half | The reference point |
| Colour depth | The format allows 10 bits per channel | 8 bits per channel |
| What one file can hold | Several images: the photo, a depth map, an HDR gain map, a burst or sequence | One image |
| Type of loss | Lossy as used by cameras | Lossy |
| Where it opens | Apple devices, recent Android, Windows with an extension; many upload forms refuse it | Practically everywhere |
What converting to JPG drops
A JPEG holds a single 8-bit picture, so everything else in the HEIC has nowhere to go. What disappears depends on how the photo was taken.
- Depth map: Portrait photos carry a depth map that lets the background blur be adjusted afterwards. The JPG is a flat picture with no depth data.
- HDR data: recent iPhones store extra brightness information that an HDR screen uses to show highlights brighter than white. The JPG keeps only the standard-range picture.
- Live Photo: a Live Photo is a still plus a short video clip stored alongside it. Converting the still gives you the still and nothing else.
- Bursts and sequences: if the HEIC holds more than one frame, only a single still is written.
- Metadata: a converter that rebuilds the file from decoded pixels may not copy the capture date, camera model or GPS position. A photo library then sorts the JPG by file date instead of the day it was taken.
When to convert and when to keep HEIC
The rule that covers all of these: the HEIC is the master, the JPG is a delivery copy. Do not delete the HEIC after converting, because a JPG cannot be turned back into what the HEIC was.
- Convert when an upload form, marketplace or web app rejects the file. This is the most common reason and there is no way around it.
- Convert when the recipient uses older Windows software, an older Android phone or a print service that lists only JPG.
- Keep HEIC for your own archive. It takes half the storage and it is the only copy that still has the extras.
- Keep HEIC for anything you may edit later, since depth and HDR data are what make Portrait and highlight adjustments possible.
- Skip converting when sharing between Apple devices, and check first when mailing a photo from the phone: the iOS share sheet often converts to JPEG on its own.
What a conversion does to size and quality
Decoding a HEIC and encoding a JPEG is a second lossy pass. At a high quality setting the added loss is hard to see, but it is real, and the file grows rather than shrinks. The ConvertBox HEIC to JPG tool decodes each file in the browser and writes a JPEG at a fixed quality of 92 with the same pixel dimensions; there is no quality slider, and the result is usually larger than the HEIC, often about double. It accepts files up to 50 MB each and several at once, with a ZIP download for the set. Decoding runs in JavaScript rather than on the hardware decoder a phone uses, so it is slower than a native app, and a large batch of 48-megapixel photos can exhaust memory on a phone or an older laptop.
If the JPG is then too big for an upload limit, shrink it as a separate step. The image compressor has a quality slider that starts at 80 and scales any image whose longest side exceeds 1920 pixels down to 1920. The general image converter is not a substitute for the HEIC step in most browsers: it opens HEIC only where the browser decodes the format natively, which in practice means Safari.
How to stop the phone producing HEIC
Most Compatible has a price. Photos take roughly twice the storage, the same switch moves video recording to the older H.264 codec, and some high-resolution, high-frame-rate video modes are offered only under High Efficiency. If storage is tight, leave the camera on High Efficiency and convert only the photos that have to leave the phone.
- iPhone camera: Settings > Camera > Formats > Most Compatible. New photos are saved as JPEG; photos already taken stay as they are.
- iPhone export over a cable: in the Photos settings, set Transfer to Mac or PC to Automatic, and the phone hands over compatible files.
- Windows 10 and 11: install the HEIF Image Extensions from the Microsoft Store to open HEIC without converting anything.
- Android: some phones offer a high-efficiency photo option in the camera settings. Turn it off to get JPEG.