ConvertBox Logo
ConvertBox

MP3 vs WAV vs FLAC vs AAC: lossy and lossless audio explained

WAV stores raw samples, FLAC stores the same samples in less space, and MP3 and AAC permanently discard what the ear is least likely to miss. Conversion can only preserve or reduce quality, never add it, so the format to keep is the best copy you have.

ConvertBoxPublished

PCM: the uncompressed audio every format starts from

Digital audio begins as PCM, a list of measurements of the sound wave. Two numbers define it. The sample rate is how many measurements are taken per second; it must be at least twice the highest frequency to be captured, so the 44,100 Hz used on CDs covers up to 22.05 kHz, just past the roughly 20 kHz limit of human hearing. The bit depth is how finely each measurement is recorded; each bit adds about 6 dB of dynamic range, so 16 bits give about 96 dB.

Multiply them out and you get the bitrate of CD audio: 44,100 samples Γ— 16 bits Γ— 2 channels = 1,411,200 bits per second, or 1,411 kbps. One minute is 1,411,200 Γ— 60 Γ· 8 = 10,584,000 bytes, about 10.6 MB, and a 4-minute song about 42 MB. A WAV file is normally just this PCM data behind a short header, which is why the size of a WAV depends only on its duration and never on what the music sounds like.

Lossless compression: FLAC keeps every sample

FLAC shrinks PCM the way a ZIP file shrinks a document: it finds patterns, stores them more compactly, and reproduces the original samples exactly on playback. The saving depends on the material, typically landing between half and two thirds of the WAV size, with sparse recordings compressing better than dense, noisy ones. FLAC also carries tags and cover art, which WAV handles poorly. Apple's ALAC does the same job inside .m4a files. Converting between WAV, FLAC and ALAC in any direction loses nothing, provided the bit depth is not reduced along the way.

Lossy compression: what MP3 and AAC remove

MP3 and AAC are perceptual codecs. They model which sounds the ear will not notice, such as a quiet tone next to a loud one at a nearby frequency, or content above the range most adults hear, and spend few or no bits on them. The bitrate is the budget: 128 kbps means 128,000 bits for every second of sound, about one eleventh of CD audio. At a constant bitrate, file size is simply bitrate Γ— duration, so 192 kbps always comes to 1.44 MB per minute.

When the budget is too small the cuts become audible. High frequencies go first, then sharp transients smear: cymbals, applause and strummed acoustic guitar turn watery well before a voice sounds wrong. That is why speech holds up at 64 kbps while dense music wants 128 kbps or more, and why many listeners cannot tell 192 to 256 kbps from the original. AAC is the newer design and sounds somewhat better than MP3 at the same bitrate, most clearly at low rates; MP3's advantage is that practically every player ever built can read it.

The formats side by side

FormatTypeStereo size per minuteSuited to
WAV (16-bit, 44.1 kHz)Uncompressed PCMAbout 10.6 MBEditing, video software, anything that will be processed again
FLACLossless, compressedRoughly 5 to 7 MBArchiving masters and CD rips
MP3 at 192 kbpsLossy1.44 MBSharing, car stereos, older players
AAC at 192 kbpsLossy1.44 MBApple devices, modern players, video soundtracks
OGG Vorbis at 192 kbpsLossy1.44 MBGames and open-source software
MP3 at 64 kbpsLossy0.48 MBSpeech, audiobooks, voice memos

Why converting MP3 to WAV or FLAC does not restore quality

Decoding an MP3 produces PCM, and that PCM can be saved as WAV or FLAC. But the decoder can only output what the MP3 kept; the frequencies and details discarded during encoding are not stored anywhere. The result is the same sound in a file five to ten times larger. Lossless describes what happens to the audio from that point forward, not the history of the audio inside the file.

Such a file can often be spotted. In the spectrum view of an audio editor, genuine CD audio reaches about 22 kHz, while audio that has been through a low-bitrate MP3 stops at a sharp shelf, often near 16 kHz for 128 kbps. A FLAC with that shelf was made from a lossy source.

Lossy-to-lossy conversion is worse than pointless, because the losses compound. Each encoder makes its own decisions about what to drop, working from a signal the previous one already damaged, so AAC to MP3, or a 320 kbps MP3 taken down to 128, adds a second generation of artefacts. The working rules are short: keep a lossless or original copy, make every lossy version from that copy, and never raise the bitrate of a lossy file, since a 128 kbps MP3 re-encoded at 256 kbps is twice the size and slightly worse.

What ConvertBox's audio tools actually write

Browser tools tend to hide encoder settings, so the output is worth knowing before you choose one. None of these tools has a sample-rate or channel selector, and each lossy pass through them is a new generation.

  • Convert Audio: MP3, AAC and OGG Vorbis are always 192 kbps; FLAC is lossless; WAV is always 16-bit PCM, so a 24-bit source loses bit depth and FLAC is the safer lossless target. The source's sample rate and channel layout are kept. Files up to 100 MB.
  • The AAC option, here and in the other tools, writes a raw .aac stream, not an .m4a file; some music library software expects .m4a.
  • Compress Audio: always a constant-bitrate MP3, at a rate you choose from 64 to 256 kbps, whatever format went in. There is no mono downmix or variable bitrate mode.
  • Volume adjustment: always a 192 kbps MP3, even for a WAV or FLAC source, so keep the original.
  • Cut Audio: saves as MP3 at 192 kbps, AAC at 192 kbps or 16-bit WAV, and re-encodes on every cut or remove; removing a middle section passes through an intermediate MP3 step even when WAV is selected.
  • Video to Audio: re-encodes the soundtrack to MP3 or AAC at 192 kbps, FLAC, or 16-bit WAV, from videos up to 200 MB. Most video carries lossy AAC or Opus, so FLAC or WAV here avoids a further lossy pass but does not add quality.

Which format for which job

  • Sending audio to other people or playing it on unknown hardware: MP3, at 192 kbps for music and 64 to 96 kbps for speech.
  • Editing, mixing or importing into video software: WAV, or FLAC if the editor accepts it, so that no lossy pass is added before the final export.
  • Archiving a CD rip or a recording you may convert again: FLAC. Every other format can be made from it later without stacking losses.
  • Listening on Apple devices, or keeping files small at a given quality: AAC.
  • An hour of lecture or a podcast episode: a low bitrate is enough. At 64 kbps an hour is about 29 MB, against about 635 MB as CD-quality WAV.

Tools mentioned in this guide

Related guides

All guides